An LGBTQ+ young person attempts suicide in the United States every 45 seconds. For decades, crisis organizations assumed youth need to hear, “We’re here to help.” But what if that assumption was wrong? What if well-meaning messages about “being there” and “getting help” push young people away?
The Trevor Project, a nonprofit focused on LGBTQ+ youth suicide prevention and crisis intervention, began an experiment in 2021 using sentiment driver analysis. We discovered something unexpected: Young people trusted us more when we appeared “innovative and forward-thinking” than when we emphasized being “helpful.”
This work takes on new urgency as the organization faces unprecedented challenges: the Donald Trump administration’s executive orders have systematically dismantled federal support for LGBTQ+ youth services, including the elimination of 988’s specialized suicide prevention option that connected over 69,000 young people monthly to trained counselors. Since the 2024 election, crisis calls have surged 700 percent, while research shows anti-LGBTQ+ policies directly cause up to 72 percent increases in suicide attempts among transgender youth.
Here’s what we learned, what worked, and what we still don’t know.
When assumptions meet reality
Traditional metrics theater: Nonprofits measure what’s easy to count, not what matters. We track calls answered, emails sent, and social impressions — metrics that look impressive in board reports but reveal nothing about the organization’s actual impact. The uncomfortable truth? You can’t measure prevented suicides. When success equals nothing happening, how do you prove your worth?
The Gen Z trust gap: Our youth generations’ authenticity radar is military-grade. They’ve grown up navigating broken systems and can smell institutional condescension from miles away. Meanwhile, 60 percent can’t access mental health services anyway, and only 37 percent have LGBTQ+-affirming homes. We weren’t competing with other nonprofits; we were competing with silence.
The attribution window problem: Traditional marketing assumes rational, immediate action: See an ad, visit a website, and act within days or weeks. Crisis attribution works differently. It’s more like see a message, life continues, and a crisis hits months later at 2 a.m. The impossible question becomes: How do you ensure someone remembers you in their darkest moment, potentially months after exposure? The wrong problem built the wrong solution, calling everything we marketers know about measurement and attribution into question.
These assumptions shape how crisis organizations and nonprofit marketers operate — and I believe they’re fundamentally flawed. Through my experience leading cause-based marketing, I witnessed how our sector often relies on outdated beliefs about measurement, audience trust, and attribution. We assume we know what youth need to hear, how to prove our impact, and when our messages matter most. But these assumptions — shared across the nonprofit world — often create the very barriers that prevent us from reaching the people we’re trying to help.
Building an experiment
We needed to understand not just “Do they know us?” but “Why would they trust us?”
Launching multi-layered research with Qualtrics BrandXM, The Trevor Project tracked three key audiences: LGBTQ+ youth aged 18 to 24, along with parents and youth-facing adults such as teachers and counselors.
Weekly platform testing fed into monthly reports and quarterly strategy sessions. The key innovation was driver analysis using a correlation methodology, which asked which perceptions drove behavior. And we made a startling discovery.
We expected youth to want availability, crisis response, 24/7 access. Instead, we found that perceiving The Trevor Project as “innovative and forward-thinking” correlated with higher consideration and referral rates than traditional crisis messaging. Why?
Young people saw “helpful” as code for “you’re broken and need fixing.” But “innovative” signaled something different. It signaled that we saw young people as incalculable humans worth investing in, not problems to solve. Word of mouth emerged as our primary affinity driver, not ads or celebrity endorsements.
We abandoned linear marketing funnels and built a “recall in chaos” model. The strategy: High customer loyalty measures like Net Promoter Scores create a human recall network as people recommend an organization or service to those they know. When teachers, friends, and parents spoke positively about Trevor, they became living memory triggers. When the crisis hits, multiple touchpoints increase the probability someone remembers us.
This discovery drove organizational transformation beyond marketing. My philosophy became: If we reach and affirm LGBTQ+ youth before a crisis, they may never need us.
We shifted metrics from “crisis contacts served” to “youth affirmed,” measuring communities strengthened rather than problems handled. This wasn’t a campaign anymore. It was a hypothesis about changing outcomes entirely.
Putting the findings into action
Crisis contacts increased 100 percent as a result of the shifts we made, which sounds like failure until you realize it signals trust, not more crises. Services grew from 67,000 to more than 260,000 contacts within a year. Platform data showed YouTube, TikTok and Instagram drove youth recall, while Facebook reached supportive adults.
We built a social following of more than 2.6 million and signed up more than 500,000 accounts on TrevorSpace, an online community for LGBTQ+ young people aged 13 to 24. However, correlation isn’t causation; we can’t prove lives saved, only that engagement increased and evolved.
We also tested the “innovative” insight through visual identity change, collaborating with the creative agency Kettle on a one-in-a-decade rebrand.
The rebrand transitioned from institutional orange to vibrant gradients, utilizing a larger color palette and incorporating gradients to create a soothing effect. This approach enabled us to infuse the brand with a new, younger energy that conveys a sense of optimism and hope. We added critical features, such as a “Quick Exit” button, and partnered with LGBTQ+ artists to ensure authentic representation.
The result? We became “the cool org” for partnerships, and the market response suggests the commercial viability of the approach. ?
We generated over 80 brand partnerships by 2022 and more than $60 million in charitable revenue. AT&T extended its support with a $750,000 commitment. Abercrombie & Fitch and its customers have donated more than $2 million to The Trevor Project.
The key insight: Brands wanted association with innovation, not just crisis response.
YouTube as the unexpected platform winner — and what that says about how young people consume media
While many assume TikTok dominates among young users, YouTube consistently outperformed other platforms in both recall and engagement.
The Trevor Project’s “Sharing Space,” a roundtable series featuring conversations with LGBTQ youth and moderated by curious, open-minded adults and allies, offers one powerful example. The first episode of this educational series was moderated by a longtime supporter of The Trevor Project, Daniel Radcliffe of “Harry Potter” fame, and featured six transgender and non-binary young people having a candid, vulnerable and illuminating conversation about their journeys. The format wasn’t flashy — it was spacious, giving youth room to be experts in their own experience.
This aligns with what I refer to as the Gen Z/Gen Alpha attention paradox: These generations don’t have a “low attention span” — they simply possess a low tolerance for fluff.
This YouTube success makes more sense when viewed through emerging research on Gen Z and Gen Alpha media consumption. The Annie E. Casey Foundation notes that Gen Alpha is already showing distinct patterns: They seek “educational content over purely entertaining material” and demonstrate sophisticated content evaluation skills from a young age. They’re not just passive consumers. They’re active critics who value authenticity and learning.
What others can learn about engaging young people
Rethink your metrics: Stop counting what’s easy (calls, clicks, conversions). Start measuring what predicts impact: Net Promoter Score, perception drivers, affinity. Measuring “youth affirmed” rather than “crises handled” requires courage to tell funders why prevention metrics matter more. Warning: Boards love crisis numbers; prepare for pushback.
Your attribution model is broken: Abandon linear attribution thinking. Crisis doesn’t follow marketing funnels; build human networks instead. Focus on creating positive word-of-mouth at scale. Every person who speaks well of you becomes a potential crisis intervener. While you can’t measure this directly, you can measure network strength.
Innovation isn’t optional for Gen Z: ”Innovative” doesn’t mean tech; it means seeing young people as whole humans. Youth want partners in thriving, not just surviving. Traditional crisis messaging reinforces stigma. Innovation signals investment in their future, not just their problems. Test everything with youth advisors (they’ll let you know when you sound cringe).
What we still don’t know
Three years in, we still can’t prove this prevents suicides — maybe we never will. The “innovative” finding might be a correlation or cohort effect. There needs to be at least five to 10 years of longitudinal studies for real outcomes. Funders want immediate proof; we only have signals. Among the other knowledge gaps we still need to fill:
Access and equity gaps: Rural youth remain the hardest to reach. The “Quick Exit” button is a band-aid on the family rejection wound. Cultural and language barriers need constant attention. Platform dependence creates risk when algorithms change or access shifts.
The moving target problem: What’s innovative today is cringe tomorrow. Language shifts constantly. Platform preferences change overnight. By the time we prove something works, it may no longer be effective. Given these realities, transparency becomes essential.
The open source approach: Others need to test this hypothesis in different contexts. Track replication attempts; successes and failures both matter. Build coalitions for transparent impact measurement. Share methodologies freely. Real innovation means admitting uncertainty while inviting others to improve on what we started.
A different kind of impact story
We can’t prove this saves lives—yet. What we can prove is that understanding how youth perceive us, rather than how we hope they do, changes everything about our approach.
The nonprofit sector needs more experiments like this: transparent attempts to challenge our assumptions, even when we can’t guarantee success. The Trevor Project estimates that over 1.8 million LGBTQ+ youth in the U.S. seriously consider suicide each year, and that at least one LGBTQ+ young person attempts suicide every 45 seconds.
With these stakes, we can’t afford to wait for perfect data.
Maybe “innovative” is not the complete answer.
Maybe this approach only works for Trevor or only for now. However, if even one organization reads this and challenges their own assumptions about crisis communication, then sharing this ongoing experiment was worthwhile.